Landscape, Nature And Travel Photography

Photography By Jim M. Goldstein

Who Is Stealing Your Photos Online?

Up until recently it’s been nearly impossible to know for certain where your online photos might end up on the Internet. As we’ve heard over the years a growing vocal minority will be the first to jump on photographers complaining about online image theft stating “Get used to it. You put it online. That’s how it is.” This argument is anything but true and frustrates the hell out of photographers who know better.

It’s become clear there is a growing interest in new technologies to address the current “wild west” nature of image theft on the Internet by stock agencies and individual photographers alike. Google recently released a research paper on VisualRank that like text search assigns a weighting and ranking to images while also leveraging image-recognition software methods. Although Google is the 800 pound gorilla of search they’ve been beat to the punch by Idée Inc. who recently released a private beta of TinEye. As you’ll see in TinEye’s demonstration video they’ve created an image search that is as simple as a Google search. All an end user has to do is reference an image online or upload a low resolution image and TinEye returns results of where that image is currently found online. What is most impressive is their image matching technology that will match similar images even if they’ve been cropped, resized or Photoshop’d.

I am a born cynic, but after putting TinEye to the test with some of my photos I’ve quickly become a believer and can’t wait for them to expand their search index and hopefully implement a Google Alert like service. At the moment they’ve indexed a relatively small portion of the Internet (roughly 500,000,000 images), but they’re asking beta testers to recommend sites to index. The service at the moment is rather narrow, but I can see where this has legs to quickly expand.

Just to show an example I decided to search one of my more commonly referenced photos of the Rockefeller Center Christmas Tree in New York City. The blog post containing this image has been accessed nearly 50,000 times and it is one of my most popular photos. With out a doubt I knew this would end up somewhere it was not supposed to. In the past by monitoring my web site log I’ve caught a few people using the image with out my knowledge, so I figured this would be a perfect example to test on TinEye.

TinEye Test - JMG-Galleries
Click to Enlarge

Sure enough I referenced the image on my blog and found a few more sites (see above) that had slipped by me who have been using my photo without my knowledge or permission.

Granted the jury is still out with TinEye, but my initial experience has been a good one. The simplicity of the interface, the image-recognition capabilities and speed at which it finds images has caught my eye. I’ll definitely be watching TinEye as it develops and provide feedback through its beta stage.

If you’re curious to try TinEye let me know in your comment to this post. I have 50 invites that I can share.

Technorati Tags: , , , , , ,

Stay Connected with Jim
Join Me On Twitter Become a Fan on Facebook
Listen to EXIF & Beyond My Latest on YouTube

Related Posts

  • frankwinters
    Hi Jim,

    I found your entry on Tineye by accident just when I needed it. I discovered yesterday that one of my popular images posted on my blog was being used by Nerve.com. Then today I discovered another user (Pace University -- another coincidence - I'm an Alumnus) -- both unauthorized. Next I backed into your entry about Tineye. I tried it and got 4 additional hits on the image (a shot of the Brooklyn Bridge).

    I sent emails to both of the first two and I'll send one to the other 4. But I guess if Tineye can find 4 with their limited database I might have more.

    This is enough to make me go back to stock photography!

    I've had 25,000 hits on the Brooklyn Bridge image. I wonder how many sales I might have had if it had been for sale. I used to think that hey - its only a low res image. But that's all you need for web use.

    Yeah -- time to go back to stock, methinks. (I do have a gallery in my town and our first 3 months were great -- I am much more interested iselling prints to actual people but a few bucks from the net would come in handy)

    Any suggestions?

    Thanks,
    Frank
  • frankwinters
    An update.

    I used Bing.com search engine to find my photo of the Brooklyn Bridge. Bing found 10 other unauthorized uses of it! Tineye only found 4, But bing didn't find all of the ones that Tineye did. So I don't know how many times the photo has been used but its more than a dozen.

    I did put the image up on a stock sight and within less than an hour someone put it in their shopping cart. I guess I've been asleep at the switch.

    Frank

    P.S. Just played around with Bing again. It thinks one of my very simple images of a lake with lots of sky and water have been copied all over the world dozen of times but it is picking up anything similar at all and tagging it as a copy. I guess there are still some bugs, eh?
  • iancpenguin
    Between this and the watermark explanations, you've helped me a lot today in putting my foot out the door. I knew I needed to watermark, but I wouldn't have thought about the copyright things either, just like you said you didn't.
  • Arlene
    TinEye does not always work. Each photographer has to remember to put some unseenable codes in the pics before they upload it in the internet. I heard tineye can recognise the pics if the photographers did so (eventhough the pics are re-named by the thieves).

    The safest way to protect your pics from being used illegally by someone else is to put watermarks allover it.

    Does anyone know a more powerful tool than tineye ?
  • Not sure if you have any invites left, but if you do I'd love to try it. I do portrait photography and would love to know who's "borrowing" my images (http://dmphotogallery.com/).

    Aaron
  • Sounds like a very handy tool! I'm late to the party too, but I'd love an invite if there are any left to be found.
  • Realizing that I've come into this party a month late, if you have any invites left, I'd love one. While I dont think I'm nearly important enough to steal from, this sounds facinating.
  • nicole armand
    I am interested in an invite also.
    Thank you,
    Nicole
  • I'm interesed in trying it. I've applied for an invite, but if you have one going spare, I'd be more than willing to try it out and let you know what I think.
  • S M
    Great post. I wonder if a new google search tool would possibly be more effective due to increased scope/cache? Would love to try TinEye if invites are still available.
  • Hi, This sounds like a great tool! Thanks for bringing it to our attention. I'd love to try it out if you still have invites.
    Thanks!
    Petra
  • Hi,

    I would like to try TinyEye.

    Would be glad to receive an invitation from you(if you are still left with invitations :D)

    Thanks,
    NaveenKumar.
  • jon
    This sounds really good. Would love to try it if you could possibly send an invite. Thanks

    jon
  • It sounds like magic! The internet is great but has so many negative aspects.
    I've started to upload smaller sizes and including a copyright on images with the hope that it is too much trouble to get it off.

    I'd love an invitation to try it

    Charlene
  • Who would want to steal images, you know with the lowering cost of digital cameras.. ;-)

    TinEye looks pretty great, I can't wait to try it. Now they should just partner with somone to email / invoice people who "borrow" work without asking.

    Adam in Phoenix.
  • DRoOpY
    Wow, this is very ineteresting... hook me up if you can!
  • If you still have any invites left, I'd be very grateful for one. I'm nowhere near professional photography standard, but I have two flickr images that seem to have massive hits, and although I google them, I fear they are being used but not coming up in google searches. Especially when my stats reveal search terms like "free wizard image" and "free mountain image" have come up!

    Thanks a lot for your help, and the article was a really insightful read.
  • Jorge
    This is by far the most interesting thing I've read so far this year. Very promising! Send me an invite if you have any left. Thx
  • Charmaine
    I sent u an email about the invite before, and you told me to drop a line here =] I'd love to try TinEye, so it would be great if you could send me an invite. Thanks again, Jim! =D

    - Charmaine
  • Any invites still available? would love to give it a try.
  • I'm a concert photographer who has been fighting with several users on Ebay and online in general who are stealing and selling my photos. Cease and desist letters always seem to work well, but the trick is to find these people in the first place. I'd love to get an invite if that is at all possible. Thank you for posting this; I've been waiting for something like this for quite a bit.
  • Funda Hemimoglu
    Sorry, l have some more to add;
    Congratulates on your work, you know you are best. You are young and have lots of years full of success.
    l must give my especial thanks by your link to one of your friends; Mr. Dan Calistrat ,whom l got your name; he is great too.
    Good Luck(Salute from Turkey)
  • Funda Hemimoglu
    l would be very very happy to see your pictures taken all over this nice world.
    Thank you if you'll do.
  • Looks like im too late, I would like to try it though. Thanks for the info!

    -Corey
  • Toby Smithe
    Hey, still got any invites? I'd be very glad if one appeared my way :)
  • Got the invite. Thanks, Jim!
  • Jim
    Just in case people are arriving to this post late I still have invites.
  • Thanks for the info Jim...if there are anymore I would love to test..I understand if you are max out.
  • Jim, I'd like to try this out if you still have any invites. Thanks, Geoff.
  • Wow! Amazing!! I would lovelovelove to try it!!
  • Hey, Jim. This is a great thing. Finally, right? I'd love an invite if you still have one.
  • I would love to have a TinEye invite. BTW it's such a great name!
    Thanks!
  • Jim
    Just got more invites... leave a comment and I'll relay one to you if you're interested.
  • I'd love to have a go at the service if/when you get more invites.
  • Jim
    I'm out of invites at the moment. As soon as I get more I'll be sure to pick up on inviting those that comment here. Sorry Brian I ran out just before you commented.
  • The service sounds great, if you (or any other commenters by now) have an invite code, I would love to try them out.
  • I'd like to try TinEye if you have an invites left. Thanks much! Very interesting...

    Ciao,
    Mati
  • Hi,

    Can I have an invite please, this tineye tool looks amazing...

    Cheers

    Mark
  • Flemming Gade
    Hi Jim,

    Looks quite interesting!
    I'd love to try it!

    Have a great weekend
    Flemming
  • Ben
    Hi Jim,

    I'd appreciate an invite if there are still any available.

    Cheers,

    ben
  • Bill Woolf
    Interesting, I would like to try it. Than you for the information about this new technology.
  • Ilse
    I would like to try it.

    Ilse (gorgopis)
  • Jim, I'd be interested in trying the search product.

    Thanks

    Don
  • Wow, one of the reasons I don't post a lot of my work. However this tool would possibly open that up so I could share more of the killer photos I have to solicit folks for prints, etc.

    Thanks for bringing this to our attention Jim!
  • I'm definitely interested, it's a common discussion and "problem" that we all share.
  • bruce eichman
    thank you! sounds like an unfortunate, yet necessary, bit of technology...love to give it a try should you have an invite left...thanks again
  • Jim -

    Thank you for sharing this. If you still have an invite left, I'd love to give this a try.

    Thanks a lot.

    - Adam George
    Embrace Life
  • Sounds like an interesting bit of technology. I would love to give it a try. Thanks!
  • Jyoteen Majmudar
    I would love to give it a go. thanks Jim.
  • Good find. Any invites still available?
  • Hey Jim-

    Very interesting technology, indeed. I'd love to have an invite to the service if you have any left... I'm curious if any of my images are being used "out there" without my permission.

    Thanks!
    Kurt
  • Hi Jim, sign me up too. Thanks
    Brad
  • jim -

    this is interesting. love to try it.

    matt
  • Hey Jim,

    Please send me an invite. Everyone once in awhile, I'll have a photo with a suspicious number of hits and it always leaves me curious as to where it's ended up.

    Thanks,

    looey
  • Hi Jim,

    I'm out of the office right now, but I would love to give it a try when I get back.

    Thanks!

    Ron
  • Gary Simmons
    Very interesting.... I would love an invite to Tineye, if you don't mind.
  • Hi Jim, thanks for the tipp. I'd definitely like to check it out. Would you please also end me an invite?

    Thanks,
    Claudia
  • s4to335
    Hey Jim...put me on your list. Thanks.

    Steve
  • Now that my blog is back working the way it should I wanted to relay an update that I still have invites. If you're not commenting because you're assuming I'm out think otherwise.
  • Jim,

    Great post. I would also love to be added to your list.

    Thanks,
    Sherri
  • I don't think my stuff is of the caliber for theft, but I'd love to try it out and see if I've got a reason to be more cautious.
  • Hi Jim,

    I would love to try the service. I've had a few negative experiences with individuals and companies using my photos without permission. It's very frustrating. One thing that I'd add to your argument is that image theft can put photographers at some legal risk, too, when they're licensing images for exclusive usage and image thieves infringe on that license. Anyway, TinEye sounds like a great technology and I'd love to test it out. Thanks!
  • I'd like an invite - thank you.

    tsteele93 A T yahoo . youknowwhat
  • jason
    interesting article, would love to a invite for tineye, not that iam expecting to find many people who have stolen my images ( i hope)

    cheers

    Jason
  • Dave
    Don't know how many times I've had to hunt down people stealing my images. I'd love to try it.

    Thanks,

    Dave
  • I would also love an invite, I'd really like to try this out. Thank you!
  • paul s
    I would like an invite as well, this could truly be a remarkable product when fully developed.
  • Tom
    Sounds interesting. I'd love an invite too. Thanks!
  • Me, me, me! :-)

    Jim, if you could get me an invite, that would be great.

    One word of caution, though: the worst offenders will probably NOT found by the search as TinEye still needs to somehow spider the web. If they do and behave like good bots, they respect robots.txt rules. But the heavy infringers usually block bots from the areas where the infringement happens.

    But I agree that such a service is a very positive step into the right direction, enabling us to defend our copyrights in an increasingly competitive market.
  • Good to see that you are keping yourself busy despite the broken toe!

    If you still have an invite left, I would love one.

    Thanks!

    PS: Long time no see... we should meet up some time.
  • Do you see the email address that is required for posting? Just in case not: cmi.per at gmail.com

    Thanks again.
  • I would love to test it out. Send an invite my way as well.
  • Hi Jim - I'd love to try out the service, if there are any invites left?
  • Thanks for the article and review. I would be interested in an invite While I do post all of my photos under CC BY-NC I still find them being used against CC often enough that this would be handy.
  • Esther G. Ure
    I would be very interested in trying it out. What a fantastic bit of information!
  • Jim,

    About time a tool like this is developed. Would be interested in trying it out. Thanks.

    Tony
  • I'm very interested in trying it out. I do Google searches, have Google alerts, and a few other things, but I'm sure there are a few that slip through the cracks for me, too.
  • I'd like an invite, please. Thanks!
  • I'd love one, thanks.

    luca dot filigheddu at gmail dot com

    Luca
  • ahockley
    As a photographer and blogger I'm always looking for solutions such as these; if you have an invite code I'd love one.
  • I'd love to try it. Maybe I can find a few more of the sites that used my "Aflac duck" photo from a few years back.

    BTW - have you tried the wp-super-cache plugin? That may help with the load on your server, and on the new server too of course. More info and download link at http://ocaoimh.ie/wp-super-cache/
  • I'd like to try it, Jim! Thanks for the offer.

    Edie
blog comments powered by Disqus

Featured Photos


Subscribe Via Email
Follow Me On Twitter Subscribe with iTunes
Subscribe to the EXIF and Beyond Podcast

Newsletter

Sign-up to the JMG-Galleries mailing list to receive periodic updates on workshops, programs, tips, articles of interest and more!

Recent Comments:

What I'm Reading

Image of Digital Photography Best Practices and Workflow Handbook: A Guide to Staying Ahead of the Workflow Curve